The Weight of Hidden Expectations: When We Care with Attachment
Introduction
Somewhere between detachment and deep investment, there’s a space where our expectations sit quietly, until they don’t.
A coaching client, an experienced executive leader, recently reflected on how he initially felt at peace with the idea of not securing a new executive role right away. The market was soft, and logically, he understood this wasn’t about his capability. He was patient, calm, and composed. Until one day, he wasn’t.
The shift didn’t come from external rejection or an unexpected setback. It came from a hidden expectation he hadn’t acknowledged, an unspoken assumption that “a few months” would be enough time. When that expectation wasn’t met, the calmness cracked and overwhelm threatened to take its place.
He hadn’t just cared about the outcome; he had cared with attachment. And beneath that attachment, something deeper stirred, his ego had become inflamed by the perceived mismatch between his expectations and reality.
This isn’t just about job searches. It’s everywhere in leadership, relationships, and personal growth. And here’s the most important thing: Hidden expectations aren’t a flaw—they’re human.
Hidden expectations: The unseen mental contracts
Hidden expectations are agreements we make with reality that reality never signed. They often show up disguised as:
- Time-based assumptions - “I’ll feel okay waiting… as long as it’s not too long.”
- Reciprocity expectations - “I invest in my people, so they will stay loyal.”
- Identity validation – “I’ve worked hard, so I should get recognised for it.”
- Fairness beliefs - “If I lead well, I should get the next opportunity.”
The problem isn’t that we care. Caring is human. The challenge comes when we attach conditions to our care without realising it. When things don’t unfold as expected, the gap between assumption and reality becomes a breeding ground for frustration, self-doubt, and resentment. And often, at the heart of that tension is the inflamed ego, reacting to a perceived threat to our sense of self, competence, or worth.
Why hidden expectations create stress
1. Hidden expectations: The unseen mental contracts
- We think we’re mentally prepared for uncertainty, but our brain is secretly running a script about how things “should” go.
- When that script is disrupted, stress isn’t just about the event, it’s about the loss of the expected timeline or outcome.
2. They make resilience conditional
- If someone believes they’re okay “as long as” an outcome happens within a reasonable timeframe, what happens when that timeframe extends?
- Their sense of calm was never unconditional, it was unknowingly tethered to an invisible deadline.
3. They shift disappointment into personal failure
- It’s one thing to say, “The market is slow”
- It’s another to feel, “Maybe I’m not good enough”
- Hidden expectations often fuel self-judgement and misplaced meaning
4. They stir the ego’s need for validation – which is often fear in disguise
- The ego thrives on a sense of control, competency, and recognition. When reality doesn’t align with its expectations, it reacts, sometimes subtly, sometimes with full- blown frustration.
- Beneath this frustration is often fear, fear of insignificance, fear of not being enough, fear of being overlooked.
- An inflamed ego makes it personal: “This isn’t just about the job market; this is about me.”
- But what if it’s not? What if the ego’s discomfort is just another sign of an unseen expectation being exposed? When stress arises from hidden expectations, it’s rarely about the event itself, it’s about what we made the event mean. When we assume things should happen in a certain way or within a specific timeframe, we unintentionally set traps for ourselves. Recognising these moments for what they are allows us to step back and reclaim our agency. The goal isn’t to detach completely, but to hold our desires with a lighter grip, one that allows for adaptation rather than resistance.
Normalising hidden expectations (because they’re Inevitable)
Hidden expectations aren’t a weakness, they’re part of how we make sense of the world. They help us set goals, make decisions, and stay motivated. The issue isn’t having them, it’s when they stay unexamined, silently shaping our emotional responses. Instead of resisting them, we work with them.
1. Identify the hidden contract (Bring it into awareness)
- What unspoken assumptions am I carrying? Are they based on facts, or are they stories I’ve created in my mind?
- What invisible timeline have I created? Am I imposing an unnecessary deadline that’s adding pressure?
- What "if-then" conditions have I placed on my patience or peace? Am I waiting for a specific outcome before allowing myself to feel at ease?
2. Shift from ‘Expectation’ to ‘Intention’ (and open up multiple pathways)
Expectation assumes a single, rigid pathway to success. Intention recognises that multiple pathways exist, and progress can take different shapes. Instead of being fixated on one outcome unfolding in a specific way, intention allows us to remain engaged while being open to alternative possibilities.
- Expectation: “I will land an exec role within a few months”
- Intention: “I will stay engaged in the process whilst exploring other options and adjust as I go”
One creates tension when unmet, as it hinges on things unfolding in just one way. The other creates momentum by embracing adaptability, allowing for unexpected opportunities and different routes to the same goal.
3. Tune into your body’s response (Signals of expectation in disguise)
- Often, we realise a hidden expectation isn’t being met not through thought, but through emotion and sensation.
- Frustration, tension, impatience, these are signals that an expectation is being challenged. Pay attention to where this shows up physically: a tight jaw, shallow breath, or a knot in your stomach.
- Before reacting, ask: “What expectation just got challenged? What is my body trying to tell me about what I wanted to happen versus what is happening?” And what fear might be underneath?”
Final thoughts
Hidden expectations shape how we lead, how we work, and how we respond to uncertainty. When they go unexamined, they create suffering. When we bring them into the light, they lose their grip. Maybe it’s not the world that’s disappointing you. Maybe it’s the silent contract you didn’t realise you signed.
So next time you feel frustration rising, ask yourself “What hidden expectation just got exposed?”
Still Curious?
Sign up for our newsletter and get just the right amount of stimulating content to help you make waves in the right direction.
